Home Detention Dilemma: Public Opinion on Penal Reform

Recently, Saifuddin Nasution asserted that the government has agreed in principle to implement the License Prisoner Release program via Home Detention. He said that prison reforms were needed to help reduce congestion in prisons and promote community correction for inmates.


  • The conversations on Home Detention Proposal garnered around 5K mentions with 14.7K social interactions that potentially reached 4.2M users for the past 7 days.
  • Public sentiment regarding the introduction of Licensed Release of Prisoners via home detention, primarily for individuals with sentences of 4 years and below, is multifaceted. While some segments of society view it as a commendable step towards humanizing the criminal justice system and addressing prison overcrowding, others harbor reservations and suspicions. A notable concern among a portion of the populace is the perception that this initiative could serve as a means for the government to relocate high-profile figures like Najib Razak to home detention, rather than incarceration in prison facilities.
  • Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution’s assertion that the use of electronic monitoring devices would ensure the proper tracking of released prisoners has elicited both support and skepticism. Some applaud this emphasis on humane treatment and technological supervision, while others question the feasibility and efficacy of such monitoring, particularly concerning potential risks to public safety. Moreover, Saifuddin’s mention of the success of existing rehabilitation programs in curbing recidivism rates has drawn attention to the broader strategies employed to address prison overcrowding and associated costs.
  • Despite statistics indicating promising outcomes, such as a low rate of re-offending among released prisoners, there remains a lingering skepticism about the comprehensive implications of home detention. Transparency and accountability in the selection process for eligible prisoners, as well as the monitoring mechanisms put in place, are crucial focal points for ensuring public trust and confidence in this initiative. Consequently, a nuanced and thorough examination of the implementation framework, along with continued dialogue with the public, is imperative to address the diverse array of opinions and apprehensions surrounding this issue.

Top online conversations on Home Detention Proposal